The best private courses in Commack, New York
Course Vaults is a golf course logging app where members have logged 12,317 rounds in New York and rate what they played. These are the 25 highest-rated private clubs within about 25 miles of Commack, New York, ranked by those community scores.

The Creek
Locust Valley, NY, USAPrivateCharles Macdonald & Seth Raynor
- 4.5Conditions
- 5.0Layout
- 4.9Scenery
- 4.3Facilities
The Creek was such a cool layout. Really enjoyed the history of the property, especially the old cemetery tucked between holes. Unfortunately, it was extremely foggy the day we played, so I missed out on some of the views of Long Island Sound.
Written by
@jensencastle
- Must play
- Views
- Caddies

Garden City Golf Club
Garden City, NY, USAPrivateDevereux Emmet & Walter Travis
- 5.0Conditions
- 5.0Layout
- 3.1Scenery
- 2.0Facilities
- Must play
- Walkable
- Caddies

Piping Rock Club
Locust Valley, NY, USAPrivateCharles Macdonald
- 4.9Conditions
- 4.5Layout
- 3.8Scenery
- 4.2Facilities
Another phenomenal club I was fortunate enough to play right after The Creek. Much larger property, but the routing and layout are top notch. Template holes galore including the OG American Biarritz.
Written by
@RLavernia
- Must play
- Walkable
- Fast greens

White
Glen Oaks Club
Old Westbury, NY, USAPrivateJoe Finger
- 4.5Conditions
- 3.0Layout
- 4.7Scenery
- 2.6Facilities
- Pristine
- Driving range
- Fast greens

Meadow Brook Golf Club
Jericho, NY, USAPrivateDick Wilson & Brian Silva
- 4.5Conditions
- 3.9Layout
- 3.0Scenery
- 3.7Facilities
An amazing championship layout that really goes under the radar in golf rich LI. A real test no matter what tee you play. A cool drivable par 4 (5) and cool short Par 5 finishing hole.
Written by
@BirdiesAvenue
- Pristine
- Restaurant
- Challenging

Westchester Country Club
Rye, NY, USAPrivateWalter Travis
- 4.8Conditions
- 4.3Layout
- 4.0Scenery
- 4.5Facilities
- Challenging
- Must play
- Pristine

South
Westchester Country Club
Rye, NY, USAPrivateWalter Travis
- 5.0Conditions
- 4.4Layout
- 4.4Scenery
- 4.8Facilities
- Restaurant
- Bar
- Locker rooms

The Apawamis Club
Rye, NY, USAPrivateWillie Dunn Jr. & Maturin Ballou
- 5.0Conditions
- 4.7Layout
- 3.7Scenery
- 4.5Facilities
Not a long golf course, but the greens will challenge you with the best of them. If your pace is just a touch off, you can find yourself a long way from the hole. A ton of great tee shots with the elevation changes on the course.
Written by
@MSwenson6
- Must play
- Pristine
- Fast greens
Huntington Crescent Club
Huntington, NY, USAPrivateDevereux Emmet & Alfred H. Tull
- 4.7Conditions
- 3.2Layout
- 3.2Scenery
- 2.0Facilities
- Driving range
- Must play
- Pristine

Shorehaven Golf Club
East Norwalk, CT, USAPrivateRobert White
- 5.0Conditions
- 5.0Layout
- 5.0Scenery
- 4.5Facilities
- Challenging
- Driving range
- Grass range

Woodway Country Club
Darien, CT, USAPrivateWillie Park Jr. & Mark Mungeam
- 4.0Conditions
- 4.0Layout
- 4.0Scenery
- NRFacilities
Classic Willie Park Jr course. Post Reno with the trees taken out has created a more open enjoyable round. Greens are fast & firm. Keeps asking you questions on each hole - fun round
Written by
@SackLodge
- Challenging
- Driving range
- Must play

Deepdale Golf Club
Manhasset, NY, USAPrivateDick Wilson
- 4.0Conditions
- 3.6Layout
- 3.0Scenery
- 4.0Facilities
Layout is crammed into a pretty small piece of land that is very hilly. Still a few really cool holes and a good overall course. The greens are some of the craziest that I have ever seen, can make for a frustrating round if you are above the hole.
Written by
@BirdiesAvenue
- Walkable
- Fast greens
- Driving range

Sands Point Golf Club
Sands Point, NY, USAPrivateA .W. Tillinghast
- 4.5Conditions
- 4.5Layout
- 3.0Scenery
- NRFacilities
- Pristine
- Driving range
- Restaurant

Wee Burn Country Club
Darien, CT, USAPrivateDevereux Emmet & Ron Forse
- 5.0Conditions
- NRLayout
- NRScenery
- NRFacilities
Some forgettable holes, but the good ones were pretty good. A little too quirky at times, but in phenomenal shape. Met Open played extremely difficult, think -1 was a 2 man playoff
Written by
@FlatironFlusher
- Driving range
- Restaurant
- Bar

Country Club of Darien
Darien, CT, USAPrivateAlfred H. Tull
- 5.0Conditions
- 4.0Layout
- 2.5Scenery
- 4.5Facilities
Course is really solid all around. Cool layout, interesting holes, a good mixture of different types of holes. Probably doesn’t get the respect it deserves because of all the good courses around it. Really fun.
Written by
@BirdiesAvenue
- Driving range
- Restaurant
- Bar

Brookville Country Club
Old Brookville, NY, USAPrivateSeth Raynor
- 4.3Conditions
- 3.8Layout
- 3.2Scenery
- 3.5Facilities
Really fun Raynor hidden gem. A few template holes, lightening fast greens. Could be up there but gets overshadowed by some of the greats along the north shore
Written by
@Chris Gotterup
- Pristine
- Fast greens
- Locker rooms

Huntington Country Club
Huntington, NY, USAPrivateDevereux Emmet & Robert Trent Jones Sr.
- 3.5Conditions
- 3.0Layout
- 2.3Scenery
- 2.5Facilities
A classic Deveruex Emmet course, Huntington is decently fun track. Layout and design is not spectacular, but the grounds crew does a very good job. Fast greens and more than 1 gettable 4s make it interesting.
Written by
@bedson
- Walkable
- Driving range
- Grass range
St. George's Golf & Country Club
East Setauket, NY, USAPrivateDevereux Emmet
- 4.3Conditions
- 4.6Layout
- 3.9Scenery
- 4.0Facilities
Had a Day yesterday at Devereux Emmet’s masterpiece. Long Island stands alone as the Mecca for unparalleled great golf courses in America. Everyone knows of NGLA, Shinnecock, Friars, Maidstone….the list goes on and on. But, only the true golf course crazy’s know of St George’s.
Written by
@wesley1
- Must play
- Fast greens
- Hidden gem
Cold Spring Country Club
Cold Spring Harbor, NY, USAPrivateSeth Raynor & Robert Trent Jones Sr.
- 4.0Conditions
- 3.0Layout
- 3.0Scenery
- 2.8Facilities
- Driving range
- Pristine
- Fast greens

The Seawane Club
Hewlett Harbor, NY, USAPrivateDevereux Emmet
- 4.0Conditions
- 2.3Layout
- 2.5Scenery
- 3.0Facilities
- Restaurant
- Driving range
- Links

Indian Hills Country Club
Northport, NY, USAPrivateAlfred H. Tull
- 4.5Conditions
- 4.0Layout
- 4.5Scenery
- NRFacilities
- Fast greens
- Strategic
- Scoreable

Greenwich Country Club
Greenwich, CT, USAPrivateSeth Raynor
- 4.0Conditions
- 3.5Layout
- 4.0Scenery
- 3.5Facilities
- Challenging
- Driving range
- Restaurant

Nissequogue Golf Course
St. James, NY, USAPrivateStephen Kay & Edgar Senne
- 4.3Conditions
- 5.0Layout
- 5.0Scenery
- NRFacilities
- Driving range
- Hidden gem
- Restaurant

The Mill River Club
Oyster Bay, NY, USAPrivateGerald Roby
- 4.3Conditions
- 3.8Layout
- 3.5Scenery
- 4.5Facilities
- Challenging
- Driving range
- Pristine

The Round Hill
Round Hill Club
Greenwich, CT, USAPrivateWalter Travis
- 4.5Conditions
- 4.0Layout
- 3.3Scenery
- 4.5Facilities
- Walkable
- Challenging
- Driving range
How we rank
Course Vaults ranks private golf courses by Course Vaults Score (CV score), a community rating from golfers who have played and rated each course. Only open courses with at least 5 explicit ratings qualify, and this list is limited to private courses (not guest-friendly). City pages include private golf courses within about 25 miles of Commack, so nearby suburbs can appear on the same list. Rankings refresh about hourly as new ratings come in; each page shows when it was last generated.
FAQ
Common questions about private course rankings in Commack, New York.
The top private golf courses in Commack, New York on Course Vaults are led by The Creek with a Course Vaults score of 9.1. This page ranks 25 courses, including The Creek, Garden City Golf Club, Piping Rock Club.
Course Vaults ranks private golf courses by Course Vaults Score (CV score), a community rating from golfers who have played and rated each course. Only open courses with at least 5 explicit ratings qualify, and this list is limited to private courses (not guest-friendly). City pages include private golf courses within about 25 miles of Commack, so nearby suburbs can appear on the same list. Rankings refresh about hourly as new ratings come in; each page shows when it was last generated.
Yes. The Commack, New York list includes private golf courses within about 25 miles of Commack, not only courses whose city field is an exact match. Nearby suburbs can appear when they fall inside that metro radius.
The Creek is currently #1 among private courses in and around Commack, New York on Course Vaults at 9.1 out of 10.
This ranking was last refreshed Nov 12, 2026, 3:49 AM EST. The page revalidates about every hour as golfers add new explicit ratings that meet the 5-rating minimum.
More cities in New York
- Purchase
- Rochester
- Rye
- Southampton
- East Hampton
- Garden City
- Riverhead
- Scarsdale
- Bridgehampton
- East Aurora
- East Farmingdale
- Huntington
- Lawrence
- Locust Valley
- Mamaroneck
- Old Westbury
- Scarborough
- Voorheesville
- Westhampton Beach
- White Plains
- Albany
- Amenia
- Ardsley-on-Hudson
- Armonk
- Baiting Hollow
- Bedford
- Bolton Landing
- Brewster
- Briarcliff Manor
- Bronxville
- Cold Spring Harbor
- Croton-on-Hudson
- East Norwich
- East Setauket
- East Williston
- Elmsford
- Fayetteville
- Fishers Island
- Glen Cove
- Glen Head
- Hartsdale
- Hastings-on-Hudson
- Hempstead
- Hewlett Harbor
- Hopewell Junction
- Inwood
- Ithaca
- Jericho
- Lake Success
- Larchmont
- Lewiston
- Lincolndale
- Manhasset
- Mattituck
- Mount Kisco
- New City
- New Rochelle
- North Salem
- Northport
- Old Brookville
- Oyster Bay
- Pelham Manor
- Pittsford
- Plandome
- Port Jefferson
- Port Washington
- Queensbury
- Rockville Centre
- Roslyn Harbor
- Sag Harbor
- Sands Point
- Shelter Island Heights
- Sparkill
- St. James
- Syracuse
- Troy
- Tuxedo Park
- Victor
- West Nyack
- Williamsville
