The best private courses in Fishers Island, New York
Course Vaults is a golf course logging app where members have logged 12,317 rounds in New York and rate what they played. These are the 9 highest-rated private clubs within about 25 miles of Fishers Island, New York, ranked by those community scores.
Fishers Island Club
Fishers Island, NY, USAPrivateSeth Raynor
- 4.8Conditions
- 4.5Layout
- 4.6Scenery
- 3.7Facilities
Time capsule experience with template holes, modest length and adherence to the past. The setting cannot be replicated anywhere.
Written by
@Gdub201
- Must play
- Views
- Walkable
Main
Shelter Harbor Golf Club
Charlestown, RI, USAPrivateDr. Michael Hurdzan
- 4.0Conditions
- 4.3Layout
- 4.7Scenery
- 4.6Facilities
- Pristine
- Must play
- Challenging
Misquamicut Club
Watch Hill, RI, USAPrivateDonald Ross
- 4.5Conditions
- 4.3Layout
- 4.7Scenery
- 4.8Facilities
- Walkable
- Views
- Challenging
Black Hall Club
Old Lyme, CT, USAPrivateRobert Trent Jones
- 5.0Conditions
- 5.0Layout
- 4.0Scenery
- 4.0Facilities
Pristine and pure RTJ track. With many dog legs and elevated, seriously protected greens, bring your A game
Written by
@greco
- Challenging
- Driving range
- Must play
North
Course at Lake of Isles
North Stonington, CT, USAPrivateRees Jones
- 5.0Conditions
- 3.4Layout
- 3.8Scenery
- 3.6Facilities
Absolutely can’t recommend this course enough if you’re looking for a great fall golf experience in New England. I’ve played here last few years in October and it’s been a great experience, skip the summer rates and get out here when the foliage is prime!
Written by
@Jolfer
- Driving range
- Restaurant
- Views
Gardiner's Bay Country Club
Shelter Island Heights, NY, USAPrivateWilliam F. Mitchell & Seth Raynor
- 4.5Conditions
- NRLayout
- NRScenery
- NRFacilities
- Driving range
- Restaurant
- Bar
East Hampton Golf Club
East Hampton, NY, USAPrivateBen Crenshaw & Bill Coore
- 4.5Conditions
- 3.3Layout
- 2.8Scenery
- 4.0Facilities
- Underrated
- Pristine
- Fast greens
South
Course at Lake of Isles
North Stonington, CT, USAPrivateRees Jones
- 4.0Conditions
- 3.5Layout
- 4.5Scenery
- NRFacilities
- Challenging
- Driving range
- Must play
Winnapaug Country Club
Westerly, RI, USAPrivateDonald Ross
- 3.0Conditions
- 3.0Layout
- 3.0Scenery
- NRFacilities
- Driving range
- Restaurant
- Bar
Explore more Fishers Island rankings
How we rank
Course Vaults ranks private golf courses by Course Vaults Score (CV score), a community rating from golfers who have played and rated each course. Only open courses with at least 5 explicit ratings qualify, and this list is limited to private courses (not guest-friendly). City pages include private golf courses within about 25 miles of Fishers Island, so nearby suburbs can appear on the same list. Rankings refresh about hourly as new ratings come in; each page shows when it was last generated.
FAQ
Common questions about private course rankings in Fishers Island, New York.
The top private golf courses in Fishers Island, New York on Course Vaults are led by Fishers Island Club with a Course Vaults score of 9.6. This page ranks 9 courses, including Fishers Island Club, Shelter Harbor Golf Club, Misquamicut Club.
Course Vaults ranks private golf courses by Course Vaults Score (CV score), a community rating from golfers who have played and rated each course. Only open courses with at least 5 explicit ratings qualify, and this list is limited to private courses (not guest-friendly). City pages include private golf courses within about 25 miles of Fishers Island, so nearby suburbs can appear on the same list. Rankings refresh about hourly as new ratings come in; each page shows when it was last generated.
Yes. The Fishers Island, New York list includes private golf courses within about 25 miles of Fishers Island, not only courses whose city field is an exact match. Nearby suburbs can appear when they fall inside that metro radius.
Fishers Island Club is currently #1 among private courses in and around Fishers Island, New York on Course Vaults at 9.6 out of 10.
This ranking was last refreshed Nov 12, 2026, 4:01 AM EST. The page revalidates about every hour as golfers add new explicit ratings that meet the 5-rating minimum.
More cities in New York
- Purchase
- Rochester
- Rye
- Southampton
- East Hampton
- Garden City
- Riverhead
- Scarsdale
- Bridgehampton
- East Aurora
- East Farmingdale
- Huntington
- Lawrence
- Locust Valley
- Mamaroneck
- Old Westbury
- Scarborough
- Voorheesville
- Westhampton Beach
- White Plains
- Albany
- Amenia
- Ardsley-on-Hudson
- Armonk
- Baiting Hollow
- Bedford
- Bolton Landing
- Brewster
- Briarcliff Manor
- Bronxville
- Cold Spring Harbor
- Commack
- Croton-on-Hudson
- East Norwich
- East Setauket
- East Williston
- Elmsford
- Fayetteville
- Glen Cove
- Glen Head
- Hartsdale
- Hastings-on-Hudson
- Hempstead
- Hewlett Harbor
- Hopewell Junction
- Inwood
- Ithaca
- Jericho
- Lake Success
- Larchmont
- Lewiston
- Lincolndale
- Manhasset
- Mattituck
- Mount Kisco
- New City
- New Rochelle
- North Salem
- Northport
- Old Brookville
- Oyster Bay
- Pelham Manor
- Pittsford
- Plandome
- Port Jefferson
- Port Washington
- Queensbury
- Rockville Centre
- Roslyn Harbor
- Sag Harbor
- Sands Point
- Shelter Island Heights
- Sparkill
- St. James
- Syracuse
- Troy
- Tuxedo Park
- Victor
- West Nyack
- Williamsville
