The Mill River Course
Oyster Bay, NY, USA





The Mill River Club, a fixture of Oyster Bay's golfing landscape since the Golden Age, represents a nuanced blend of classic design and challenging play within the rolling hills of Long Island. The terrain favors strategic shot-making over brute force; many tee shots demand careful consideration of angles, rewarding those who can work the ball around its subtle doglegs. It is a golf course built for matchplay. Designed originally by Herbert Strong, the course has seen nips and tucks from lesser known architects, which contributes to the current layout featuring undulating greens guarded by deceptively deep bunkers. The tight fairways lined by mature trees requires accuracy and finesse, making par a worthy accomplishment. Mill River remains a well-respected club within the region, a challenging layout providing a stern test of golf for its membership. It is as close knit group, often sharing a smile and a story, and maybe a nip of scotch, after a well played round. The clubhouse is also renowned for its traditional clam bake, a summertime ritual celebrating the bounty of the nearby Long Island Sound.
Ranked by CV ratings from golfers who've played this course. Positions are shown worldwide, by country, and by state; the Private column compares member-only and guest-restricted courses.
Best in World
Unranked
Best in USA
Unranked
Best in NY
All courses
8.0
20 players
Greens are wild.
Public courses closest to The Mill River.
FAQ
Ratings, design, and course details pulled from Course Vaults.
The Mill River has a Course Vaults score of 8.0 out of 10 based on 12 explicit golfer ratings.
The Mill River was designed by Gerald Roby.
The Mill River is listed as private on Course Vaults; guest access is typically restricted.
Par at The Mill River is 72.
The Mill River plays 6,623 yards from the back tees on Course Vaults.
The slope rating at The Mill River is 126.