Top Private Golf Courses in Shelter Island Heights, New York
The top private clubs around Shelter Island Heights, New York, ranked by golfers who’ve actually played them — not magazine lists or marketing scores. 20 courses made this list. These are members-only clubs, and every course needs a handful of real ratings before it appears. Last refreshed .
9.7(National of America) National Golf Links of America
Southampton, NY, USA
+57
9.6Shinnecock Hills Golf Course
Southampton, NY, USA
+57
9.5Fishers Island Club
Fishers Island, NY, USA
+51- 9.5
Friar's Head
Riverhead, NY, USA
+45 
9.0(West) Maidstone Club
East Hampton, NY, USA
+35
8.7Sebonack Golf Course
Southampton, NY, USA
+21
8.6Southampton Golf Club
Southampton, NY, USA
+5
8.6Atlantic Golf Club
Bridgehampton, NY, USA
+2
8.6The Bridge Golf Club
Bridgehampton, NY, USA
+17
8.2Gardiner's Bay Country Club
Shelter Island Heights, NY, USA
8.1Laurel Links Country Club
Mattituck, NY, USA
+11
8.1(East) Maidstone Club
East Hampton, NY, USA
+1
8.0Baiting Hollow Club
Baiting Hollow, NY, USA
+3
8.0Noyac Golf Club
Sag Harbor, NY, USA
+5
7.9Black Hall Club
Old Lyme, CT, USA
+2
7.9East Hampton Golf Club
East Hampton, NY, USA
+7- 7.8
Hampton Hills Golf & Country Club
Westhampton Beach, NY, USA
7.7The Vineyards Golf Club
Riverhead, NY, USA+2
7.6Madison Country Club
Madison, CT, USA
7.4Long Island National Golf Club
Riverhead, NY, USA
How we rank
Course Vaults ranks private golf courses by Course Vaults Score (CV score), a community rating from golfers who have played and rated each course. Only open courses with at least 5 explicit ratings qualify, and this list is limited to private courses (not guest-friendly). City pages include private golf courses within about 25 miles of Shelter Island Heights, so nearby suburbs can appear on the same list. Rankings refresh about hourly as new ratings come in; each page shows when it was last generated.
FAQ
Common questions about private course rankings in Shelter Island Heights, New York.
The top private golf courses in Shelter Island Heights, New York on Course Vaults are led by National of America with a Course Vaults score of 9.7. This page ranks 20 courses, including National of America, Shinnecock Hills, Fishers Island.
Course Vaults ranks private golf courses by Course Vaults Score (CV score), a community rating from golfers who have played and rated each course. Only open courses with at least 5 explicit ratings qualify, and this list is limited to private courses (not guest-friendly). City pages include private golf courses within about 25 miles of Shelter Island Heights, so nearby suburbs can appear on the same list. Rankings refresh about hourly as new ratings come in; each page shows when it was last generated.
Yes. The Shelter Island Heights, New York list includes private golf courses within about 25 miles of Shelter Island Heights, not only courses whose city field is an exact match. Nearby suburbs can appear when they fall inside that metro radius.
National of America is currently #1 among private courses in and around Shelter Island Heights, New York on Course Vaults at 9.7 out of 10.
This ranking was last refreshed Aug 11, 2026, 1:12 AM EDT. The page revalidates about every hour as golfers add new explicit ratings that meet the 5-rating minimum.
More cities in New York
Browse all states · Want filters and the full matrix? Explore on Leaders.
