The best-conditioned golf courses in Fishers Island, New York
The golf courses within about 25 miles of Fishers Island, New York that Course Vaults golfers rate highest for conditions: greens, fairways, tee boxes, and bunkers. Each course needs conditions ratings from at least 5 different golfers who played it; 7 courses qualify.
Also covers Montauk.
Main
Shelter Harbor Golf Club
Charlestown, RI, USAConditions 4.8 out of 5 from 6 golfers
PrivateDr. Michael Hurdzan
- 4.8Conditions
- 4.3Layout
- 4.7Scenery
- 4.6Facilities
- Pristine
- Must play
- Challenging
Fishers Island Club
Fishers Island, NY, USAConditions 4.2 out of 5 from 30 golfers
PrivateSeth Raynor
- 4.2Conditions
- 4.5Layout
- 4.6Scenery
- 3.7Facilities
Time capsule experience with template holes, modest length and adherence to the past. The setting cannot be replicated anywhere.
Written by
@Gdub201
- Must play
- Views
- Walkable
Meadow Brook Golf Club
Wyoming, RI, USAConditions 3.9 out of 5 from 6 golfers
PublicRoger Rulewich & Dave Fleury
- 3.9Conditions
- 4.0Layout
- 3.8Value
- 2.8Scenery
- 2.7Facilities
- Hidden gem
- Underrated
- Great value
North
Course at Lake of Isles
North Stonington, CT, USAConditions 3.8 out of 5 from 5 golfers
PrivateRees Jones
- 3.8Conditions
- 3.4Layout
- 3.8Scenery
- 3.6Facilities
Absolutely can’t recommend this course enough if you’re looking for a great fall golf experience in New England. I’ve played here last few years in October and it’s been a great experience, skip the summer rates and get out here when the foliage is prime!
Written by
@Jolfer
- Driving range
- Restaurant
- Views
East Hampton Golf Club
East Hampton, NY, USAConditions 3.6 out of 5 from 6 golfers
PrivateBen Crenshaw & Bill Coore
- 3.6Conditions
- 3.3Layout
- 2.8Scenery
- 4.0Facilities
- Underrated
- Pristine
- Fast greens
Island's End Golf & Country Club
Greenport, NY, USA
Conditions 3.3 out of 5 from 8 golfers
Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course
Montauk, NY, USA
Conditions 3.3 out of 5 from 19 golfers
How we rank
This ranking uses each golfer’s conditions rating, on a 0.5–5 scale. Conditions is the golfer’s overall conditions score, or the average of their greens, fairways, tee box, and bunker scores when no overall was given. Every golfer counts once per course: repeat rounds are averaged first, then the course score is the average across golfers. A course needs conditions ratings from at least 5 different golfers. Ties go to the course with more golfers, then the higher Course Vaults score. Only open courses with a published Course Vaults score (at least 5 explicit ratings) are eligible, and a page is published only when at least 5 courses qualify. City pages include courses within about 25 miles of Fishers Island, so nearby suburbs can appear. Rankings refresh about hourly.
FAQ
Main at Shelter Harbor Golf Club is #1 on Course Vaults in and around Fishers Island, New York at Conditions 4.8/5 (6 golfers). 7 courses qualify for this list.
This ranking uses each golfer’s conditions rating, on a 0.5–5 scale. Conditions is the golfer’s overall conditions score, or the average of their greens, fairways, tee box, and bunker scores when no overall was given. Every golfer counts once per course: repeat rounds are averaged first, then the course score is the average across golfers. A course needs conditions ratings from at least 5 different golfers. Ties go to the course with more golfers, then the higher Course Vaults score. Only open courses with a published Course Vaults score (at least 5 explicit ratings) are eligible, and a page is published only when at least 5 courses qualify. City pages include courses within about 25 miles of Fishers Island, so nearby suburbs can appear. Rankings refresh about hourly.
A course appears once at least 5 different golfers have rated its conditions on Course Vaults. Log your round and rate it in the app to help it qualify.
Yes. It includes qualifying courses within about 25 miles of Fishers Island, not only courses whose address is in the city.
This page was last generated Nov 12, 2026, 4:26 AM EST. Scores and eligibility are recomputed about every hour.
